There was a recurring Henny Youngman bit, directed at either the show host or the roast subject, that went
Thank you, Milton/Ed/Alan etc. I'm going to Israel, when I'm there I'll have a tree uprooted in your honor.
Can someone explain that joke?
Re: Light laffs
Posted: 10 Apr 2021, 17:19
by dhex
It's thst trees planted in memory of loved ones, i'm presuming?
Re: Light laffs
Posted: 10 Apr 2021, 17:33
by Kolohe
That's what I figured, I just never have come across it. Surprised it was significant enough Jewish-American mid 20th century tradition to be a punchline with no explanation for Gentile-included audiences. (and the internet doesn't have a ready explanation)
There's another punchline that goes 'kid, shut up and eat your cranberries' that the internet does explain (apparently a big carcinogen problem/scare that drew widespread public attention with some chemical they were using in cranberry bogs)
Re: Light laffs
Posted: 10 Apr 2021, 19:28
by D.A. Ridgely
dhex wrote: ↑10 Apr 2021, 17:19
It's thst trees planted in memory of loved ones, i'm presuming?
I don't know whether it was connected with memorializing the dead, but when I was young and Israel was still a new Jewish state, paying to plant trees "in the desert" was a thing routinely done among American Jews and as a result American Jewish comedians from the Borscht Belt era made in-jokes about it.
I guess maybe the goyish equivalent was those little boxes they handed out in school every year for kids to save pennies to give to UNICEF? *shrug*
dhex wrote: ↑10 Apr 2021, 17:19
It's thst trees planted in memory of loved ones, i'm presuming?
I don't know whether it was connected with memorializing the dead, but when I was young and Israel was still a new Jewish state, paying to plant trees "in the desert" was a thing routinely done among American Jews and as a result American Jewish comedians from the Borscht Belt era made in-jokes about it.
I guess maybe the goyish equivalent was those little boxes they handed out in school every year for kids to save pennies to give to UNICEF? *shrug*
Pretty sure this is correct. I can remember Jewish kids talking about giving money to plant trees in the desert as part of expanding and solidifying Israel. I even think you're right about it being an annual nickle and dime fundraising deal.
Re: Light laffs
Posted: 10 Apr 2021, 20:10
by Aresen
I know the 'plant trees to memorialize the dead' thing does happen, but I'm not sure if it applies in this case.
Re: Light laffs
Posted: 10 Apr 2021, 20:31
by D.A. Ridgely
Aresen wrote: ↑10 Apr 2021, 20:10
I know the 'plant trees to memorialize the dead' thing does happen, but I'm not sure if it applies in this case.
It's popular with environmentalists to have a tree planted on top of the dearly departed, but I don't know if its roots are Jewish.
Aresen wrote: ↑10 Apr 2021, 20:10
I know the 'plant trees to memorialize the dead' thing does happen, but I'm not sure if it applies in this case.
It's popular with environmentalists to have a tree planted on top of the dearly departed, but I don't know if its roots are Jewish.
I know there was a line of trees planted in England to memorialize Canadian pilots killed in the Battle of Britain. (There was a little foofahrah a few years back because the brits chopped them down to widen a road.)
Aresen wrote: ↑10 Apr 2021, 20:10
I know the 'plant trees to memorialize the dead' thing does happen, but I'm not sure if it applies in this case.
It's popular with environmentalists to have a tree planted on top of the dearly departed, but I don't know if its roots are Jewish.
I know there was a line of trees planted in England to memorialize Canadian pilots killed in the Battle of Britain. (There was a little foofahrah a few years back because the brits chopped them down to widen a road.)